Debate #4- Roleplaying: Being a Bad Guy

The Drunken Lancers debate Roleplaying in Freelancer. To what extent can a player explore and establish their in-game lifestyle & morality? The Lancers discuss the style of play they prefer the most, how prepared they are to take risks, and whether they're prepared to achieve their goals at any cost.

Throughout this debate series, The Drunken Lancers are split into three separate categories, depending on how they play the game. As in Freelancer, alignment is represented by colors: Green for good, Red for bad and White for neutral.

The stampede begins..

Session Start: Sep 23 18:22:40 2005
*** Now talking in #thetapasbar
*** Gunbeard changes topic to 'Roleplaying Bad Guys'
*** Joins: Rhodan

*** Joins: chilli
*** Joins: Badchoice
chilli: THE BEARD
Gunbeard: ahoy chilli
Badchoice: nono, your meant to say "THE HOT BEAN"
chilli: haha, chilli isnt a bean its a vegetable
Gunbeard: im pretty sure its a fruit.
Badchoice: its an edible rock
chilli: lol
Gunbeard: right, no more muckin about, get straight to it.
*** Joins: Knuckles
chilli: fashionably late
Knuckles: whut?
Badchoice: omgz knuckles your two minues late!&$*$&
Gunbeard: Right ye scurvy bastards shut up and get on with it
Rhodan: I had the time to read the other debates, and there is always a period of chaos at the beginning.
Gunbeard: ..yes rhodemeister, thank you for that observation.
chilli: but rhodo, this is the age of the beard, hes in charge now
Rhodan: Please don't remind me.

So I cut a lot of crap out so we could get to the frickin' DISCUSSION..

Gunbeard: okay, so give me an idea of what you like and dont like about player pirates in Freelancer, and the choices involved when you choose to be a pirate or a bounty hunter/anti-pirate, and the moral implications this can have.. ok?
Badchoice: that gave me a headache
chilli: I like beard's idea of honorable piracy.
Knuckles: waitim still reading it
Gunbeard: go on, chilli
chilli: well you've got to be straightforward about being a pirate, but you have to have a code of honor if you're going to be respected. respect is a big step towards being a good pirate.
Gunbeard: that's right, being a pirate and being a player-killer are two different things, if you show people you are a reasonable player who is not completely unfair, you can get better results and even get regular taxpayers.
Badchoice: no man lots of server rules say a pirate is a player killer who can tax
Knuckles: if you just torch the life out of them every time they see you and they keep coming back, its their own fault. once they realize as soon as they see you they are going to get toasted, they will listen to your demands and pay up.
chilli: thats what makes you guys dishonorable pirates, its not as simple as good or bad, you can mix and match to get the results you want, right?
Badchoice: right i guess, but i prefer shoot first demand stuff later, cos otherwise they wont know if your capable of doing them damage or not.
Knuckles: yeah thats what i mean, you have to send a message you mean business
Gunbeard: I prefer to wait and see what they do next. It's more fun to punish someone who doesnt believe you than it is to straight away blow them up and start a war when you could have started a mutual agreement.
chilli: ive seen it work man, hes only had a few payback hunts out of about twenty new taxpayers, and none of them lasted more than a day.
Gunbeard: right and sometimes id just be able to talk my way out of trouble instead of getting a whole bunch of kids with grudges trying to pin me in one system.
Knuckles: ok so pirating isnt all the same, we get it!

On to the next section..

chilli: alright, we have piracy and degrees of honor, or types of pirate behavior etc, what next?
Gunbeard: we still have bullying smaller ships and cargo taxation to go
chilli: right, so if im in an eagle and i tax tiny ships, that makes me dishonorable as a pirate
Gunbeard: aye, thats pretty straightforwardly dishonorable, yes
Knuckles: dude thats what taxing is about, noone escapes!
Gunbeard: yes and theres nothing wrong with that if thats how you want to play it, its just dishonorable is all.
Knuckles: well gee whiz should i apologize when i tax?
Badchoice: lol awfully sorry old chap but would you mind forking over a few credits for me grans wobbly knee surgery.
Knuckles: lolol
chilli: its like karma, right, if youre going to behave badly, be sure you can cope with the consequences.
Rhodan: Johann and I are a few of those consequences.
Badchoice: oh no! rhodan spare me!!!!
Knuckles: look hes so manly and frightening!!11
Gunbeard: haha
chilli: hehe, no but its true man, peeps like rho and jo are anti-pirate by nature, but rhodan is like a dishonorable anti-pirate, he just kills them whenever he likes.
Gunbeard: im enjoying this.. do go on chilli
Rhodan: It's really not that funny.
Gunbeard: Well my wrinkly old chum, if you think about it, Freelancer is all about freedom to choose what you want to do, so being a pirate is a legitimate choice, and degrees of behavior convey degrees of honor, so if you hunt down pirates mercilessly, you are essentially prejudicing every pirate as having done something to deserve destruction apart from choose a role.
chilli: haha, youre giving knuckles brain damage
Knuckles: auuugh again with the reading hugeness
Rhodan: Yes it is a choice, but my choice in dealing with pirates without mercy counteracts the pirates who deal with players without mercy, I am the balance to the force.
Gunbeard: aye, i get what youre saying, but don't you think that as a good guy you have a greater responsibility to show understanding and - you know - GOODNESS to pirates who might actually have honor and might cooperate at being restricted to certain systems or taxed if theyre spotted by you?
Rhodan: That has been attempted, but the degree of treachery and dishonesty amongst pirates has brought me to cement my reputation as a no-mercy pirate killer.
chilli: lol, methinks our guy has been hurt in the past
Gunbeard: Well a certain someone left the mighty to pursue a career in piracy..
Rhodan: I wasn't talking about you, Mr.Gun.
Gunbeard: :)
Rhodan: Look, my role is to protect the whole of Sirius from the scourge of piracy. I choose to be a hero to the entire region, that is my role and I play it well.
Gunbeard: bravo!
chilli: fair enough, rhodo, you've made your case
Knuckles: eesh he's a hero
Badchoice: CAPTIN RHODAN HES A HERO!!111
chilli: rhodo, dude, look what you've done now.
Rhodan: I've merely stated my case and defended my right to defend Sirius.
Badchoice: GONNA BRING POLLUTION DOWN TO ZEEERO!1
Gunbeard: lol.. alright choice quit it let's get on with it.
Badchoice: :) he's my hero *weep*
Knuckles: lmao

And finally the summaries..

Gunbeard: alright you filthy scum, summarize what you think about player piracy and how big a deal it is to be a bad guy in Freelancer.
Rhodan: You know where I stand, I am against pirates of any kind, and will destroy any and all I meet without a moment's hesitation.
Knuckles: blahblabhlabhlabh blahblah hesitation.
Badchoice: lol well said that man, well said.
chilli: I want to hear what the BEARD has to say about all this nonsense.
Gunbeard: why sir, don't mind if i do :}
Gunbeard: There is an art to piracy, you can be a charmer and then folks will deal with it better. The more you make yourself part of the whole atmosphere the more readily theyll hand over the cargo.
Badchoice: but there are always players who will just quit out of the server or not care if theyre blown up, or just go to war with you or something.
Gunbeard: yes but youve got to present an argument, cos you're just playing a role. If you're gonna be a pirate that picks on players, you might as well get in character and do it properly, otherwise you'd just be running trade, which would net you more money anyways.
Rhodan: Most players aren't in character and are just trying to enjoy the game, so when you kill them you're wasting their time and effort, which is completely wrong.
Gunbeard: Look I know that some poor beggar has toiled for fifteen minutes on a trade route and been lane hacked a dozen times and then i come along and demand his cargo, but im only buggering around in a Wolfhound or something similar, so im only asking for about forty units out of one or two hundred.
chilli: ive done that myself a few times with choice, we hung around new tokyo, robbing people on the diamond run. wasnt that successful really cos once they knew about us they took really long pain-in-the-ass detours, and i wouldnt wish that kind of boredom on anyone.
Badchoice: oh man, the old days
Gunbeard: aye if you get that reputation theyll even start talking about you on the forums
Badchoice: yeah forum threads on pirates, haha. and flames against pirate posters whove robbed people before, thats always fun.

Rhodan: I rely on my reputation to strike fear into the hearts of pirates throughout Sirius and the server forums.
Knuckles: oh geez.
Badchoice: lol.. rhodan.. hardly anyone remembers you.
chilli: ah but dude, pirates have no heart, so they cannot have fear struck into them!
Gunbeard: lol shut it.
Gunbeard: ANYWAY.. roleplaying a pirate is really enjoyable cos once you get in the role you find you have a reputation with REAL players, and thats very rewarding, because its not just the AI that you have to look out for, every time you see a player up on your Important Contacts List, you're thinking 'wonder if they know about gunbeard' and when they say 'ah sh%t' then you know they know and you go 'arrrr hand it over, forty units, no more, no less.'

Badchoice: aw yeah reminds me of the NRA in Kusari
chilli: lol.. good times. oh and some insane times too, like the Kyushu convoy on that cloud run to Hokkaido.
Badchoice: dude we have to tell that one, Gunbeard do a tales section for the site man please.
Gunbeard: ok, seeing as its the first time you've ever spelt my name fully and capitalized it.
chilli: lol he must really want it. but yeah thats a good idea so yes please mr. beard.
Gunbeard: alright ye swabs, lemme finish..
Gunbeard: so. its great when you have a big reputation as an honorable pirate because then you can start a whole debate about whether pirates in the server should be allowed to mess up big trade runs. I think its great, you can hijack an entire trade run, and i've done that on entire servers. It's just great.
chilli: so what im getting from you is that its great?
Badchoice: hahahaha
Gunbeard: alright shut it, anyone else?
Knuckles: lemme try
Gunbeard: ok go ahead
Badchoice: gee whiz, TODAY knuck
chilli: lol, give him a chance man
Knuckles: ok so being a pirate means taking something aswell as killing, so taxing and cargo robbing basically makes you a pirate, but killing players without wanting anything just makes you a murderer.
Knuckles: ok?
Badchoice: dude that was horrible.
Knuckles: LOL omg you a$$
chilli: hehe, choice why dont you summarize then
Badchoice: ok remind me of the topic
Gunbeard: scroll up and see, ye lazy sod.
chilli:
topic is being a bad guy, what makes you choose and why
Badchoice: thanks CHILLI. no thanks BEARD.

Gunbeard: lol
Knuckles: THIS WEEK, choice.
Badchoice: so, being a pirate is about making a statement to the whole server that you are a bad guy and are looking to fight and steal. Its a great role to play because its exciting and challenging and you dont have to look around for trouble, because trouble looks for you instead. oh and knuckles stfu.
chilli: awesome. good job, choice.
Gunbeard: aye, nice work chaps, now bugger off.
Knuckles: lol whut everrrr
*** Quits: Knuckles
Badchoice: ADIOS MUCHACHARINOS
*** Quits: Badchoice
chilli: he must be neutered before he becomes a threat to lampposts everywhere
Rhodan: Haha.
*** Quits: Rhodan
chilli: DUDE did you see that?!? rhodan laughed at my joke man. that never happens ever.
Gunbeard: hm, that is pretty shocking, he never laughed at any of my jokes, and i am hilarious.
chilli: lol blowing your own trumpet a bit there arent you.
Gunbeard: french horn, my good friend. french horn.

Session Closed: Sep 23 22:01:41 2005

Click here to go back to the top!